From aedcfbed9df0d0b3545486daf902bfb1725a52ae Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Kathleen Fitzpatrick <3170201+kfitz@users.noreply.github.com>
Date: Wed, 21 Oct 2026 06:33:53 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] some cuts
---
acl261021.md | 24 ++++++------------------
1 file changed, 6 insertions(+), 18 deletions(-)
diff --git a/acl261021.md b/acl261021.md
index de2ed731..c7a9cac2 100644
--- a/acl261021.md
+++ b/acl261021.md
@@ -30,12 +30,12 @@ Note: There's a direct through-line from that warning to the work I attempted in
## crisis
-Note: But thinking about what our institution has experienced as a "crisis" feels so obvious as to say absolutely nothing about what's actually happening. You, here, know this all too well: we are surrounded by crisis in the academy (not to mention the world beyond) and while our circumstances at MSU have perhaps been more intense than at some other institutions, to say that we have been facing an "institutional crisis" feels redundant.
+Note: But thinking about what our institution has experienced as a "crisis" feels so obvious as to say absolutely nothing about what's actually happening. We are surrounded by crisis in the academy (not to mention the world beyond) and while our circumstances at MSU have perhaps been more intense than at some other institutions, to say that we have been facing an "institutional crisis" feels redundant.
## permanent crisis
-Note: Institutions like ours are in many ways built on a foundation of crisis. As Paul Reitter and Chad Wellmon have explored in their book *Permanent Crisis*, the long history of the rhetoric of crisis, especially in the humanities, can be traced back to the establishment of the German university system, which of course gave shape to much of the structure of research universities in the contemporary United States. On the other hand. There are some particularities to the situation of our institutions today -- the threats that our colleges, our departments, our fields, and our researchers and instructors face -- that are not merely rhetorical, and it's worth paying some careful attention to the specifics of
+Note: Institutions like ours are in many ways built on a foundation of crisis. As Paul Reitter and Chad Wellmon have explored in their book *Permanent Crisis*, the long history of this rhetoric, especially in the humanities, can be traced back to the establishment of the German university system, which of course gave shape to much of the structure of research universities in the contemporary United States. On the other hand. There are some particularities to the situation of our institutions today -- the threats that our colleges, our departments, our fields, and our researchers and instructors face -- that are not merely rhetorical, and it's worth paying some careful attention to the specifics of
- the labor crisis
@@ -138,12 +138,12 @@ Note: In fact, most of what comes down to us from above is management rather tha
### “over-managed and under-led”
-Note: "over-managed and under-led," and universities are no exception. At every level of our institutions, we have been disciplined into an inability to cope with -- much less create -- change. Transforming our ideas about campus leadership could allow us to people together to create change, to model and to create the conditions for more thoughtful, more inclusive, more just ways of working. Leadership, in other words, ought to be about building the relationships necessary for collective action. It should be connective, and compassionate, and generative. And it could emerge anywhere in an institution, if cultivated.
+Note: "over-managed and under-led," and universities are no exception. At every level of our institutions, we have been disciplined into an inability to cope with -- much less create -- change. Transforming our ideas about campus leadership could allow us to bring people together to create change, to model and to create the conditions for more thoughtful, more inclusive, more just ways of working. Leadership, in other words, ought to be about building the relationships necessary for collective action. It should be connective, and compassionate, and generative. And it could emerge anywhere in an institution, if cultivated.
## cultivation
-Note: I choose the metaphor of cultivation pointedly, thanks to Beronda Montgomery, whose brilliant book _Learning from Plants_ explores the ways that an understanding of botanical life can help us develop more supportive, more collectively attuned ways of working in human communities. As Montgomery argues, learning from plants encourages us to focus on remediating the environments within which we work together rather than attributing the difficulties some individuals experience in taking root and growing in those environments to internal deficits. This approach also calls upon us to develop a new kind of leadership "vision," one that can turn away from gatekeeping to instead focus on what she calls *groundskeeping*, "attend\[ing] to individuals while at the same time tending the ecosystems in which these individuals exist" (Montgomery 149). These organic metaphors allow us to think about leadership as something that is grown rather than owned or inhabited, requiring an awareness that our institutions and organization are more akin to ecosystems than they are to the org charts we draw to represent them. Leaders must work in concert with their ecosystems, rather than operating from the top-down management perspective to which we have become accustomed.
+Note: I choose the metaphor of cultivation pointedly, thanks to Beronda Montgomery, whose brilliant book _Learning from Plants_ explores the ways that an understanding of botanical life can help us develop more supportive, more collectively attuned ways of working in human communities. As Montgomery argues, learning from plants encourages us to focus on remediating the environments within which we work together rather than attributing the difficulties some individuals experience in taking root and growing in those environments to internal deficits. This approach also calls upon us to develop a new kind of leadership "vision," one that can turn away from gatekeeping to instead focus on what she calls *groundskeeping*, "attend\[ing] to individuals while at the same time tending the ecosystems in which these individuals exist" (Montgomery 149). These organic metaphors allow us to think about leadership as something that is grown rather than owned or inhabited, requiring an awareness that our institutions and organizations are more akin to ecosystems than they are to the org charts we draw to represent them. Leaders must work in concert with their ecosystems, rather than operating from the top-down management perspective to which we have become accustomed.
## re-organize
@@ -173,24 +173,12 @@ Note: As a result of this devolution from shared governance into the purely advi
## merit
-Note: As Young points out, "the values of bureaucratic organization" indicate that decisions should be made "according to merit." And while the reliance on merit in bureaucracy is, she notes, among "the important positive developments in the history of social organization," what is missing is a deep engagement with and debate concerning the meaning and determination of _merit itself_. Our institutions have devised metrics and processes that allow us to believe that merit is a quantifiable thing we can assess outside the realm of the political. But merit as a category is always and inevitably ideological, in providing a common-sense explanation that transforms highly contingent relations of domination into something apparently natural. As Young argues:
-
-
-> “The rules and policies of any institution serve particular ends, embody particular values and meanings, and have identifiable consequences for the actions and situation of the persons within or related to these institutions. All of these things are open to challenge, and politics is the process of struggle and deliberation about such rules and policies, the ends they serve, and the values they embody. The ideology of merit seeks to depoliticize the establishment of criteria and standards for allocating positions and awarding benefits.” (Young 211)
-
-Note: **(READ SLIDE.)** That depoliticization sounds like a good thing — making the awarding of benefits as objective a process as possible — up until we remember that the individual people involved in defining and implementing these processes are not and can never be objective. We are all inescapably subjective, bringing our own experiences and perspectives to everything we judge. What depoliticization means in the bureaucratic, and particularly in the meritocratic, is a closing-off of the opportunities for debating the criteria, the processes, and the objectives through which we might keep notions like merit from becoming forms of oppression. As it seeks to become depoliticized, bureaucracy errs in treating the rules as the _ends_ that it seeks, rather than a _means_ to those ends.
-
-
-## peer review
-
-Note: Take, for example, peer review. I've written extensively about this, and I won't rehash all of that here. But one key point has to do with the role that anonymity plays in the process. Anonymizing the submissions that undergo peer review for publication began as a means of mitigating the influence of reviewer bias based on the identity of the author. The goal was admirable and its success has been appreciable, enabling the work of marginalized scholars to gain purchase in the highest levels of academic discourse. What anonymity did not do, however, and cannot do, is _eliminate_ bias, which will always find ways to creep back in around the edges as, for instance, critiques of subject matter, methodology, and cited sources become proxies for status based on identity and serve as ostensibly neutral means of reinforcing hierarchies within fields. Again, the intent of these rules and procedures is admirable, but they can never provide for the fullness of justice, precisely because they are treated as if they are sources of objectivity, when they are always designed and implemented by individuals with specific subjectivities.
+Note: As Young points out, "the values of bureaucratic organization" indicate that decisions should be made "according to merit." And while the reliance on merit in bureaucracy is, she notes, among "the important positive developments in the history of social organization," what is missing is a deep engagement with and debate concerning the meaning and determination of _merit itself_. Our institutions have devised metrics and processes that allow us to believe that merit is a quantifiable thing we can assess outside the realm of the political. But merit as a category is always and inevitably ideological, in providing a common-sense explanation that transforms highly contingent relations of domination into something apparently natural. Young argues that the "ideology of merit" is a *depoliticizing* force -- which sounds like a good thing — making the awarding of benefits as objective a process as possible — up until we remember that the individual people involved in defining and implementing these processes are not and can never be objective. We are all inescapably subjective, bringing our own experiences and perspectives to everything we judge. What depoliticization means in the bureaucratic, and particularly in the meritocratic, is a closing-off of the opportunities for debating the criteria, the processes, and the objectives through which we might keep notions like merit from becoming forms of oppression. As it seeks to become depoliticized, bureaucracy errs in treating the rules as the _ends_ that it seeks, rather than a _means_ to those ends.
## values
-Note: Moreover, trying to change the rules and procedures to make them _more_ objective is laudable, but cannot help but introduce new areas in which objectivity is in question. Ultimately, as Young argues, the goal should be not to exclude subjectivity or "personal values" from decision-making, but rather to make that subjectivity and those personal values fully part of the decision-making process itself, as she notes that these values are "inevitably and properly part of what decisionmaking is about." So rather than trying to make peer review more bias-free, what if we were instead to embrace its deeply political nature, to make it more transparent and participatory, and to ask authors and reviewers alike to surface and contend with their values as a part of the process?
-
-Changing a process like peer review in order to surface rather than avoid subjective bias, one might reasonably argue, would make that process political. And yet it's clear to just about everyone who has ever been through such a process that those decisions and processes _have always been political_, and will always remain political. That's not in and of itself a bad thing. We should not want to remove politics from the ways that we engage with one another on campus, but rather to create an environment in which we can embrace politics, rendering all of us able to participate wholly, fully, with the most open and honest intent in the processes through which our lives are inevitably structured.
+Note: The goal of bureaucracy is objectivity, and when that goal is obviously failing, the impulse is to change the rules and procedures to make them _more_ objective -- a laudable goal, but one that cannot help but introduce new areas in which objectivity is in question. Ultimately, as Young argues, the goal should be not to exclude subjectivity or "personal values" from decision-making, but rather to make that subjectivity and those personal values fully part of the decision-making process itself, as she notes that these values are "inevitably and properly part of what decisionmaking is about." We don't want academic processes to become purely political. And yet it's evident that institutional decisions and processes _have always been political_ in Young's sense, and will always remain political. That's not in and of itself a bad thing. We should not want to remove politics from the ways that we engage with one another on campus, but rather to create an environment in which we can embrace politics, rendering all of us able to participate wholly, fully, with the most open and honest intent in the processes through which our lives are inevitably structured.
#### politics : leadership :: bureaucracy : management