diff --git a/acl261021.md b/acl261021.md
index 5a13f046..de2ed731 100644
--- a/acl261021.md
+++ b/acl261021.md
@@ -1,5 +1,4 @@
-## Generosity in
-Challenging Times
+## Generosity in
Challenging Times
---
Kathleen Fitzpatrick // @kfitz@hcommons.social // kfitz@msu.edu
@@ -36,14 +35,14 @@ Note: But thinking about what our institution has experienced as a "crisis" feel
## permanent crisis
-Note: Institutions like ours are in many ways built on a foundation of crisis. As Paul Reitter and Chad Wellmon have explored in their book *Permanent Crisis*, the long history of the rhetoric of crisis, especially in the humanities, can be traced back to the establishment of the German university system, which of course gave shape to much of the structure of research universities in the contemporary United States. On the other hand. There are some particularities to the situation of our institutions today -- the threats that our colleges, our departments, our fields, and our researchers and instructors face -- that are not merely rhetorical, and it's worth paying some careful attention to the specifics of these crises, which include:
+Note: Institutions like ours are in many ways built on a foundation of crisis. As Paul Reitter and Chad Wellmon have explored in their book *Permanent Crisis*, the long history of the rhetoric of crisis, especially in the humanities, can be traced back to the establishment of the German university system, which of course gave shape to much of the structure of research universities in the contemporary United States. On the other hand. There are some particularities to the situation of our institutions today -- the threats that our colleges, our departments, our fields, and our researchers and instructors face -- that are not merely rhetorical, and it's worth paying some careful attention to the specifics of
- the labor crisis
- the economic crisis
- the political crisis
-Note: (**CLICK**) **The labor crisis**. Over the last couple of decades, we've watched as more and more good positions across the academy -- positions with job security, adequate salaries, full benefits, and above all academic freedom -- have been sucked into the gig economy. The effects of this labor crisis are manifold: as fewer and fewer faculty members have access to the benefits of tenure, and thus the voice in shared governance required to have a real impact on the institution's directions, our fields and our departments appear decreasingly vibrant, drawing in diminishing numbers of students, thus making the case for our apparent obsolescence.
+Note: these crises, which include: (**CLICK**) **The labor crisis**. Over the last couple of decades, we've watched as more and more good positions across the academy -- positions with job security, adequate salaries, full benefits, and above all academic freedom -- have been sucked into the gig economy. The effects of this labor crisis are manifold: as fewer and fewer faculty members have access to the benefits of tenure, and thus the voice in shared governance required to have a real impact on the institution's directions, our fields and our departments appear decreasingly vibrant, drawing in diminishing numbers of students, thus making the case for our apparent obsolescence.
- (**CLICK**) This of course works hand-in-hand with **the economic crisis** that our institutions are mired in. As public funding provides a smaller and smaller portion of university budgets, the costs of higher education have shifted radically from the state to individual students and their families. As those costs escalate, the pressure on students to think of higher education as a market exchange grows. If they're going to sink tens, or even hundreds, of thousands of dollars into the purchase of a four-year degree, it's not the least bit surprising that students would also face increasing pressure to select a degree program that seems to promise an obvious career outcome. And thus majors that are named after jobs or industries grow, and those that aren't shrink, providing further evidence that new investments in those fields are a luxury that our institutions, like our students, cannot afford.
- (**CLICK**) And in the midst of all that, there is of course **the political crisis**, which has been brewing for decades but, as we are all experiencing viscerally day to day, has taken a particularly acute turn. The attacks that we've seen on talking openly about diversity, the moves to ban books from libraries, the attempts to eradicate tenure, the growing interference in the curriculum, the decimation of research funding, the restrictions on and danger to international students and faculty -- all provide evidence of a growing backlash against the critical functions that the university brings to bear.
I point to all of this in order to suggest that neither the threats we face nor the work we have ahead are rhetorical. They are instead very material, and they demand material responses.